Narrations (2):

Q1: What is your opinion on Ibrahim ibn Hashim, the father of Ali ibn Ibrahim al-Qummi, as a narrator?

A: Both of the said persons are considered authentic.

Q2: Is the Hadith-e-Kisa Authentic?

A: There were texts narrated that the prophet gathered his household under the“Kissa”, blanket which indicate clearly that the incident took place. The narrations were different in the exact wording. At the ending of the book of Mefatihul Jinan , there is one version of this narration from some hadith books.